Night five is the fifth and final playable night of Those NIghts at Rachel's. With all the animatronics aggressively active, except Rachel due to glitches, the player must be very alert. The Thing and Ray must be checked three, even four times in an hour.

Upon completing this night, the player will receive a screen showing a paycheck and a promotion. with a Christmas tune playing. Afterwards, they will see a dark screen followed by a cutscene in a place resembling the guard's office and what could be his bedroom, showing the Thing approaching and attacking the player. The guard then wakes up in the office, and the screen fades to return to the main menu.

After beating this night, the Extras menu is unlocked for both the normal and hard versions.